Cycle 2 Votes:Prop # Title Proposer Mac Kevan Id DaveB Kont Puzz Malaprop Result Karma 2.1 McNomic Aesthetics (Kont) F A F A F F F F 5 2.2 (Untitled) (Kont) A A F U A F A A -4 1 (Kont) 2.3 Where am I? (Dave B) F F F F A F F F 6 2.4 Enough Is Sometimes Too Much (Dave B) F A F F F F F F 6 2.5 The Evil WebPage Designer (Dave B) F F A F A F F F 5 2.6 But I Don't Like Stone! (Dave B) F A A F A A F A -4 13 (Dave B) 2.7 Simpler Calvinball (Kevan) F F A U F F F F 5 2.8 Grab Wars (Kevan) F U F U F F A F 4 2.9 Say No More (Kevan) A U A U A F A A -4 2.10 Karma, Kafka, Krona, Kudos (Kevan) F F A A F A F F 4* 2.11 Rewriting the Ruleset (Kevan) A F A A A A F A -5 2.12 Proposal Merger (Kevan) A F A A F A F A -4 2.13 Clarity Begins At Home (Kevan) A F F A U F A A(t) -3* 2.14 I Don't Think We're In Kansas Anymore... (Kevan) A F A A A A F A -5 2.15 Power to the People! (Kevan) F F F A A F A F 4 2.16 Prodding the Snorers (Kevan) A U A A A A F A -5 -9 (Kevan) 2.17 Don't Spill the Beer (Puzz) F F F F A F F F 6 2.18 Get Involved! (Puzz) F A A F A F F F 4* 2.19 In the Beginning (revised) (Puzz) F A F F A A F F 4* 2.20 Preferred Address Change Request (Puzz) F A A U F F A A(t) -3 11 (Puzz) 2.21 Titles Revisited (Mac) F F F U F F F F 6 2.22 Ruleset Aesthetics (Mac) F F A F A F F F 5 2.23 Matter, AntiMatter and ItReallyDoesn'tMatter (Mac) F A F F F A F F 5 2.24 The Country Without a Man (Mac) F A A A F F A A(t) -4 12 (Mac) 2.25 IX.B Successful Pass (Malaprop) A F F U A F F F 4 2.26 IX.B.1 Bouncy, Bouncy, Bouncy (Malaprop) F F A U F F F F 5 2.27 IX.B.2 Three Little Pigs (Malaprop) A F A U A A A A -5 2.28 IX.C Dropping the Ball (Malaprop) F F F U F F F F 6 2.29 IX.D On The Run (Malaprop) F A A U A F F A(t) -3 2:30 IX.E Interception (Malaprop) A F F U A A F A(t) -3 2.31 IX.F Passing the Gnarly, Red, Leathery Calvinball (Malaprop) F A F U A F F F 4 2.32 IX.G Calvaries (Malaprop) A A F U A A F A -4 2.33 IX.H On The Run for Points (Malaprop) A A F U A A F A -4 2:34 III.A.4 The Tallymaster (Malaprop) A F F U F A F F 4 4 (Malaprop) Karma: Initial 37 15 19 -5 0 26 18 For Pass 17 12 13 8 10 15 17 For Fail -4 -6 -5 -1 -3 -6 -9 Against Fail 11 7 10 6 11 9 6 Against Pass -2 -6 -6 -3 -9 -4 -2 Proposal Success 12 -9 13 1 11 4 Karmic Change: 36 -2 12 23 10 25 16 Final Karma 73 13 31 18 10 51 34
* Denotes proposals whose passage or failure changed with the incorporation of Malaprop's vote.