Judgments Archive Index

[Judgments Archive Index]

1/0: Those that have declared emselves Players are not Players. : false
2/0: Those that have declared emselves players are not players. : false
3/0: There is no player by the name of Ed. : true
4/0: There is there a player by the name of Benjamin Bradley. : false
5/0: There is there a player by the name of DW. : false
6/0: A forum not declared to be a public forum by the Administrator is not a public forum. : true
7/0: Actions taken in a forum that is not a public forum are invalid. : true
8/0: Agents may not communicate via public fora. : false
9/0: Joel is the only player. : false
10/0: No Agent is an eligible voter unless a rule other than Rule 118 explicitly allows that Agent to vote. : false
11/0: The english verb "to be" is considered reflexive [ie 'x is y.' implies 'y is x.']. : false
12/0: An agent needs to be a Player to be selected as a judge. : false
13/0: Benjamin should not be listed on the Roster. : true
14/0: spoon-discuss@nomic.net is not a public forum. : true
15/0: The ruling for Judgment 13 should be "false". : false
16/0: Benjamin was a Player immediately before Judgment 13 was issued, and as such, must still be a Player since e has not forfeited and no Orders have been executed (or even issued) to remove em, and thus should by definition be on the Roster. : true
17/0: You guys are out to get me. : false
18/0: This nweek began at 00:00:00 UTC on October 2nd. : true
19/0: All Active Proposals at the beginning of the voting period became Ballot Issues at the beginning of the voting period. : true
20/0: Alterations to Active Proposals or Motions which are not recognized by the start of an nweek's voting do not alter any Ballot Issues. : false
21/0: Any post sent after an nweek's voting commences which purports to recognise changes does not alter any Ballot Issues. : true
22/0: Motions requiring a vote introduced during an nweek's voting will not become Ballot Issues. : false
23/0: Inaccurate, late, or no publication of Ballot Issues does not affected the actual state of Ballot Issues. : true
24/0: A vote which names a revision of an item which has not become a Ballot Issue can not be counted. : refused
25/0: Motions requiring a vote introduced during an nweek's voting will not become Ballot Issues, : false
26/0: The Judicial Order made by Zagarna in the Judgement on RFJ20 was invalid. : true
27/0: The Judicial Order made by Potter in the Judgement on RFJ26 was invalid. : false
28/0: Debts are not Objects as defined by Rule 316/0. : false
29/0: NomicHomes cannot be transferred. : true
30/0: It was possible to make a Request for Judgment before the 11th of November 2000. : true
31/0: Voting without notifying the Administrator of your votes is possible [[if not entirely practical]] : false
32/0: The modification Benjamin made to his NomicHome was invalid. : false
33/0: It is possible for a Player to not follow the Rules : true
34/0: The Player Joel is not in violation of R350/0. : false
35/0: The modification Benjamin made to his NomicHome was invalid. : true
36/0: Upon passage of any Bank Motion issued by the Tax Collector, a Motive Order is issued by Rule 319/0 forcing the repayment of the points specified from the debtor to the bank. : false
37/0: The Player Poulenc performed several actions after the Motive Order for repayment was issued, and therefore did not perform the required action 'as soon as possible' as stated in Rule 319/0. : true
38/0: M22, by Jeff Schroeder, text quoted below, did not result in a Motive order requiring Poulenc to transfer 30 points to the bank, because its wording and type (Bank Motion) were directed at the Bank, not at Poulenc. : true
39/0: R226/0 does not prohibit voting in private fora. : true
40/0: If a rule states certain conditions under which points should be transfered, and those conditions are met, then those points should be transfered without any action by the current owner of the points. : false
41/0: A debt is payable to the debtor unless e transferred ownership of the debt. : false
42/0: The actions of a Player who holds an Office are actions that are committed by the Player and the Officer. : true
43/0: The recusal of player Poulenc from the judgement on RFJ#40/0 and the assignement of RFJ#40/0 to player Blest Lax Monk Pal were invalid. : refused
44/0: Poulenc has not offered any Go alliances to The Kid, Dave, or M'cachessilnath. : true
45/0: Poulenc's placing of a stone on K5 on 30th March is invalid as he had already made a move on that day. The stone should be removed and Poulenc refunded his 4 points. The alliance that Benjamin offered to Jeff on 3rd April is invalid as he had already made a move on that day. The alliance should be canceled. (The re-offer of the alliance earlier today still stands.) The alliance that The Kid offered to various people on 3rd April is invalid as he had already made a move on that day. The alliance with Chess should be canceled : true
46/0: No point objects and no debt objects currently exist. : pending
47/0: As the Rules cannot be scrutinised to determine the legality of PurpleBob's win by Pooker the win should be postponed until such a time that the Rules can be scrutinised, and the deadline on making RFJ's should be similarly extended. : pending
48/0: For the Dealer to use cards from the Deck to participate in a gard of Pooker or any other Card game is clearly against the spirit of the rules and against the spirit of the game and thus is illeagal. : pending

Tue 26 Jun 2001 17:18:56 UTC Home